The 90-Day Stock Option Exercise Window After Leaving a Startup

By Shye Uy

90-day stock option exercise window: an employee leaving a startup carries out the vested part of an option grant, while the unvested portion stays behind.

Your last day at a startup starts a clock on your vested options, and the length of that clock is written in documents you received when you were granted them. Those terms are easy to overlook until notice has been given and the window is already running. The rules for stock options when leaving a startup can be read in advance, which turns a deadline into a decision.

This article is general information, not tax or legal advice.

Key Takeaways

  • Unvested options stop vesting when you leave unless your plan or grant provides for acceleration, and vested options begin a post-termination exercise period set by your plan documents.
  • The 90-day exercise window traces back to the federal rule that an ISO must be exercised within three months of employment ending to keep its ISO tax treatment.
  • Some startups, including Amplitude, Prisma, and Foxglove, have publicly extended their exercise windows to as long as 10 years from grant.
  • The cash to exercise is vested options times strike price, but the tax on the spread between strike and fair market value can be as significant as the exercise cost.
  • Your stock plan, option agreement, grant type, vested count, strike price, and current 409A value are the inputs you need before deciding.
  • Letting options expire, exercising part of a grant, and timing a departure around vesting are all legitimate choices.

What Happens to Stock Options When Leaving a Startup

Two documents control your equity at departure: the company's stock plan, which sets the defaults, and your option agreement (or grant notice), which records your specific grant and any terms that differ.

Unvested Options When You Leave

Unvested options stop vesting on your termination date. Unless your agreement includes acceleration (for example, on a change of control), they are forfeited and return to the option pool, leaving nothing to decide.

What Happens to Vested Stock Options When You Quit

Vested options stay yours for a limited time. Your plan specifies a post-termination exercise period, and vested options not exercised by its end expire. Many plans set that period at 90 days, but your documents are the only authority on your number. The same documents may set different periods for departures caused by disability or death, so check for those terms as well.

How the 90-Day Exercise Window Works, Including the ISO Three-Month Rule

Under Internal Revenue Code section 422, an employee must have been employed by the granting company (or a related company) from the grant date until the day three months before exercise for an incentive stock option (ISO) to receive ISO tax treatment. For an employee who leaves because of permanent and total disability, the statute replaces three months with one year. A plan that sets a 90-day window keeps the exercise period inside the ISO three-month rule.

What ISO Treatment Means

The IRS states that you generally do not include any amount in gross income when you receive or exercise an ISO, although you may be subject to alternative minimum tax (AMT) in the year you exercise. To get favorable treatment on the eventual sale, section 422 requires that you not dispose of the shares within two years of the grant date or within one year after the shares were transferred to you. If you sell before meeting those holding periods, the IRS treats the income from the sale as ordinary income.

ISO to NSO Conversion After Leaving

If an ISO is exercised more than three months after employment ends, the employment requirement is not met, and the Treasury regulations direct that the exercise be taxed under the rules for nonstatutory options. This is the ISO to NSO conversion after leaving: the option survives if your plan allows a longer window, but it loses ISO tax treatment. Separately, section 422 treats ISOs whose underlying stock exceeds $100,000 in value (measured at grant) first becoming exercisable in a single calendar year as non-ISOs, so part of a large grant may already be NSOs.

Extended Post-Termination Exercise Periods

An extended exercise window lets former employees exercise vested options long after the 90-day mark, in some cases up to the option's original expiration date. Section 422 caps an ISO's term at 10 years from grant, which is why extended windows are expressed as "up to 10 years from grant" rather than a fixed period after departure.

Several companies have documented their extensions publicly. Amplitude announced in December 2015 that it was extending its window from 90 days to 10 years for all employees, regardless of tenure. Prisma extended its window to 10 years in 2021 with board approval. Foxglove, a data platform for physical AI, announced in June 2023 that it was extending its window to 10 years post-grant for employees with two years of tenure.

How to Check Whether Your Startup Has an Extended Exercise Window

Search your plan and option agreement for "post-termination exercise period," "termination of service," or "expiration," and look for tenure conditions and whether an extension covers existing grants. If they are unclear, ask the equity administrator to confirm your window in writing.

How to Decide Whether to Exercise Stock Options After Leaving

The decision depends on cash, tax, and your view of the company, and the first two can be calculated before you give notice.

How Much Does It Cost to Exercise Options

The cash to exercise is the number of vested options times the strike price. The tax exposure comes from the spread between the strike price and the current fair market value, which for private companies is the 409A valuation.

As an illustrative example with round numbers (not tied to any real company), 10,000 vested options with a $1 strike price cost $10,000 to exercise. If the current 409A value is $5 per share, the spread is $40,000. For an NSO, that $40,000 is included in income at exercise. For an ISO exercised within the window, it is not regular income at exercise, but it can factor into AMT for that year. Either way, the tax side can exceed the $10,000 exercise cost.

Documents and Numbers to Gather Before Giving Notice

  • The stock plan and every option agreement or grant notice you hold
  • Grant type for each grant (ISO or NSO), including any portion over the $100,000 limit
  • Vested count as of your planned last day
  • Strike price for each grant
  • Current 409A fair market value
  • Your exact post-termination exercise period and expiration dates
  • Special terms for departure, disability, or death, plus any acceleration provisions

Options When Exercising Is Not Affordable or Not Appealing

Letting options expire is a valid outcome, and it involves no exercise or sale. If your plan permits partial exercise, you can buy a portion of your vested shares and let the rest lapse. You can also time your departure: if a vesting date falls shortly after your planned last day, staying through it changes the number of options you hold. When comparing new roles, the exercise window at the next company is worth asking about, and engineers using Fonzi to meet AI startups can raise it during offer conversations.

Conclusion

When you leave a startup, unvested options end and vested options start a countdown whose length, cost, and tax treatment are set by documents you can read today. Gather those numbers before giving notice and consult a tax professional for your situation. If you are exploring your next role, sign up at talent.fonzi.ai to connect with AI startups that are hiring.

FAQ

Do I lose my unvested options when I quit a startup?

Unvested options stop vesting on your last day and are forfeited unless your option agreement includes acceleration terms.

Is the 90-day exercise window a legal requirement?

No, but ISOs must be exercised within three months of employment ending (one year for disability) to keep ISO tax treatment, which is why many plans use 90 days.

What happens to my ISOs if my company has a 10-year exercise window?

You can exercise after three months if your plan allows it, but those exercises are taxed under the rules for nonstatutory options rather than as ISOs.

Is there a tax bill if I let my options expire?

The IRS describes option tax events at exercise and at sale, and an expired option involves neither, but confirm your situation with a tax professional.

Where do I find my exercise window?

Your stock plan and option agreement state the post-termination exercise period, and your company's equity administrator can confirm it in writing.

Keep reading